Domain Pointer Email Question

I have successfully configured my domain pointer and enabled email aliases. To test, I sent an email to [email protected] from my main @primary.com account. I then sent a reply from [email protected]. So far, so good. The trouble is, the email I received had a sender address of [email protected] - I expected it to be [email protected].

I have set the "reply from email address" against the user account, and it does appear in the email; it's just underneath the sender address.

Have I missed something? Is what I need to achieve even possible?

Thanks

 

Anyone?

Should I raise a support ticket for this?

 

Thanks for the response.

That's unfortunate. It looks like I'll need to (reluctantly) change host

 

Just to be clear (as I've now triggered a cancellation): I can have unlimited domains with my account, but there is now way to have fully functioning email accounts with each domain? I guess I'd have to have a hosting plan for each domain?

 

Ok. Thanks again for the response. I don't actually need separate sites, so that's a shame.